Justice or Small Claims:
In which court should I file?
DISCLAIMER:
This is general information only concerning uncontested procedural
matters. It does not purport to cover substantive law or address the
merits of your lawsuit and is not a substitute for sound legal
advice from an attorney. The Court Clerks are not attorneys and are
prohibited from discussing the facts of your case or answering any
legal questions.
Within the limitation of certain legislation and rules, the
Plaintiff (the person filing the suit) has the option to file suit
against the Defendant (the person being sued) in either the Justice
Court or Small Claims Court.
The filing and service fee in Small Claims for a lawsuit against one
Defendant in Webb County is $111.00. The filling and service fee for
an eviction case is $131.00.
Below is a list of differences between the courts. Please read this
information carefully before making your decision regarding the
court in which to file.
|
Justice Court
Monetary Jurisdiction up to $10,000
(excluding interest and attorney fees)
The Texas Rules of Civil Procedure and Texas Rules of
Evidence apply
A party primarily engaged in the business of lending money
at interest or a collection agent or agency must file in
justice court. Failure to comply with this rule may result
in the case being dismissed and the Plaintiff forfeiting all
costs.
An individual or an individual doing business under an
assumed name may represent themselves or may be represented
by an attorney.
|
Small Claims
Court
Monetary Jurisdiction up to $10,000
(including interest and attorney fees at time of filing)
The Court can grant a judgment only for money damages in
Small Claims Court
Formal pleading is not required. Discovery is limited as
permitted by the Judge. The Judge hears evidence from the
parties and witnesses in an informal hearing.
A party primarily engaged in the business of lending money
at interest or a collection agent may not file in Small
Claims Court.
Either party may be represented by an attorney, but an
attorney is not required. A non-attorney agent may file the
lawsuit but may not represent either party at trial.
|
Filing Suit
Step 1. Decide if you are going to sue the Defendant in Justice
Court or Small Claims Court.
NOTE:
You cannot file suit in either the Justice Court or Small
Claims Court if your claim is for more than $10,000. Instead, you
will file in a County or District Court. If you would like to
file for property it must be done at the County or District Court.
The information on “In which court should I file?” outlines the differences
between the courts. Please read this information carefully before
deciding in which court to file.
Step 2. Complete the form called “Plaintiff’s Original Petition.”
◦Provide a daytime phone number and notify the Court immediately of
changes in your address or phone number.
◦ Be as specific as you can about the named Defendant and the
capacity in which the Defendant is being sued. Your failure to
properly name the Defendant could result in your losing your lawsuit
or being unable to collect on a judgment. The three most common
legal entities are:
1.Individual (example: John Doe)
2. Sole Proprietor or Partnership (example: John Jones dba Sparkle
Cleaners)
3. Corporation (example: Superior Builders, Inc.)
Step 3. File the Plaintiff’s Original Petition and pay the court
costs/filing fees.
Step 4. Services of Process. A citation attached to your filed
Petition will be served on the Defendant by a Constable or Sheriff’s
officer. The Citation tells the Defendant the deadline for answering
the lawsuit. You should receive court notice of the date/time by
mail.
Step 5. Default Judgment or Contested Hearing: Your case is decided.
If the Defendant does not file an Answer to your Petition within the
allotted time, you may receive a “Default Judgment.” A Default
Judgment means that a short hearing will be held before the Judge
without notice to the Defendant.
◦It is your responsibility to call the Court and schedule a time for
your Default Hearing.
◦Prepare your documents and testimony in advance to show the judge
exactly how you arrived at the amount of damages that you are
claiming.
The Defendant can file an answer with the Court at any time before
the judgment is entered. This answer will entitle the Defendant to a
“Contested Hearing.” If a Contested Hearing is held, the Plaintiff
has the burden of proving his or her claims to the Court.
◦ The Court will consider only testimony and other evidence
available in the Courtroom at the time of the trial.
◦ Have copies of all the documents you intend to use at the hearing
available for the Court and Defendant.
◦ Be aware that notarized statements from individuals, although
admissible, have little value compared to live testimony.
◦ Involuntary witnesses may need to be subpoenaed (ordered to appear
in court).
Step 6. Judge’s Decision.
Step 7. Collection of the Judgment (if any).
This information is not legal advice and is no substitute for the
advice of an attorney.
Note: Please don’t ask the clerks or Judges for legal advice. The
Judge and the court staff are not allowed to give you legal advice
or act as your attorney. When you choose to represent yourself in
court, it is your responsibility to protect your rights by informing
yourself of law and procedures that affect your case.
Please note that evictions are only for past due rent.
Steps for Evictions
1. An eviction must be filed in the Justice precinct where the
rental property is located. If you do not know the Justice precinct of the property please contact the elections office at 956-523-4055.
2.Texas Property Code, Sec. 24.005 sets out the notice requirements
for eviction suits. (Unless the notice requirements are stated in
the signed lease.)
3.The notice to vacate must be in writing and should be
unconditional, i.e., it should tell the tenant to vacate by a
specific date in no uncertain terms.
4.Unless there is an agreement between the parties shortening the
notice requirements, the landlord must wait three days after the
notice to vacate is served before filing the eviction.
5.When filing, the landlord should bring the following:
a.Two copies of
the lease
b. Two copies of the notice to vacate
c. $131.00 for filing and service on one person
(additional service
is $100.00 per person)
d. All work and residence addresses and telephone numbers of the
tenant(s) known by the landlord.
6.Generally, all parties named in the lease should be sued and
served with a citation in the eviction proceeding. Any judgment
granted will run only against those who are specifically named and
served.
7.The owner's agent may file any type of eviction suit and may
represent the owner at any default judgment hearing. If the case is
contested an agent may represent either party if the case involves
non-payment of rent or holding over. The parties or their attorneys
must try all other types of evictions if the case is contested.
8. A default judgment for eviction will only be granted if the defendant is not present at trial the file must contains:
a. A
return from the constable showing the defendant was properly served
b. A copy of the notice to vacate
c. A copy of any written lease
9. A personal appearance and sworn testimony will be required of the
landlord or agent for a judgment for rent to be awarded or where the
file is incomplete (see # 10 above)
10. A court date will be set at the time the eviction is filed with
the court. This date will mailed to the known address of the defendant. Both
parties are expected to appear at that date/time. Any continuance
request must be in writing, timely and agreed to by all parties.
11.Under the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, either party to the
lawsuit has five days to appeal the courts decision. The filing of
an appeal bond or paupers oath by that time completes the appeal. A
properly filed appeal stops all further justice court proceedings
until there is a resolution by the county court-at-law.
12. If neither party appeals, the landlord may obtain a Writ of
Possession from the court after the five (5) day period for appeal
has passed. The writ fee of $111.00 is payable to JP court to cause
the tenant to vacate the premises. Questions involving the execution
of the writ should be directed to the appropriate constable's
office.
13. An Immediate Possession Bond can speed the evictions process. A corporate or affidavit of surety bond must
be filed with the court. Ask the civil clerk for details.
Forms
Note: The links to Word documents on this page will open in
a new window browser.
Eviction Petition
Plaintiff's Original Petition
Peace Bond